Home Business Black Women Nonprofit Leaders Challenge Donors to Stop Offering Paperwork Instead of...

Black Women Nonprofit Leaders Challenge Donors to Stop Offering Paperwork Instead of Money and Invest in Their Communities

5
0
Female colleagues listening to confident young businesswoman
Credit: Klaus Vedfelt

A nonprofit led by Black women can do the application, clear the paperwork, and win the grant, and the grant is twenty thousand dollars. “You jump through all these hoops, you do an application, you apply for a grant, and you get $20,000,” said Simone Hardeman-Jones, a philanthropic leader and nonprofit executive. “You’re constantly fundraising; you never get to get ahead and dream boldly about what you want your impact to be.”

Less than 1 percent of traditional philanthropy goes to organizations serving Black communities, according to data from the Lilly Family School of Philanthropy. The Giving Gap, founded in 2020 to connect donors with Black-led nonprofits, put the funding gap for those organizations at roughly $20 million in its 2024 report.

Heather Infantry, the chief executive of the Giving Gap, says the money and the advice are handed out to different people. “Philanthropy is in no way exempt from these kinds of inequities, as is health or education or any other social system,” she said. “Nonprofit organizations led by us, on the other hand, will be given things like technical assistance in lieu of dollars.” Funders, she says, “send them through an obstacle course of paperwork and applications” and the habit behind it will “masquerade as institutional policy,” while being, in her words, “very much well funded.”

Tish Johnson-Jones, a philanthropic leader and nonprofit executive, describes the circular logic that keeps a small organization small. “We want you to expand, but we don’t want to give you the resources to do that because you haven’t expanded,” she said. “It’s like, I’m just trying to keep my lights on.” She is blunter about where the decisions actually get made. “You give to who you know. You give to who you have relationships with. If I don’t know you, I don’t trust you.”

Chelsea VonChaz has been distributing period products to people on Skid Row in Los Angeles for nearly 12 years through Happy Period, which she founded and runs. She says scale is not a conversation she gets to have. “It’s kind of hard for us to talk about or have discussions about scaling when we’re so deep into keeping our operations afloat,” she said. “People are so comfortable giving the money to the white-led organization that serves Black people.” She is direct about why it has to be said out loud: “If you don’t call the thing out, they’re gonna say, ‘Oh, it doesn’t even exist.'”

Hardeman-Jones pushes back on the frame underneath all of it. “Black people are still so often seen as the recipients of the charity and not the givers,” she said. “But Philanthropy is in our DNA. Really, philanthropy is about love.”

The fix the four of them describe is not a bigger gala. It is unrestricted money, relationships that start before the ask, and giving that does not end on one Tuesday in December. “Give to our community on Giving Tuesday, on Wednesday, Thursday, and throughout the year,” Infantry said. “It’s an all-of-us project, every day, 365.”

Previous articleTiffany Cross Opens Up About Leaving Native Land Pod to Return to the Journalism She Has Practiced for 27 Years

LEAVE A REPLY